Metate Cabo Review: A Disappointing Second Visit

Our honest Metate Cabo review after a November 8, 2026 visit: friendly but stretched service, disappointing food, loud music, and hopes for a better.

Metate Cabo: at a glance

A disappointing November 8, 2026 return: food 5/10 (down from 9/10 on our previous visit), service 6/10, ambiance 5/10. Very nice staff, but the team seemed stretched; we plan to try again next year.

Best For

Consider Elsewhere

Travel Resources · Saved places

The string-lit garden dining area at Metate Cabo
The string-lit garden dining area at Metate Cabo.

By Nicholas & Miriam Peters · Published 2026-11-09 · Seen in person 2026-11-08

We returned to Metate Cabo on November 8, 2026, hoping to repeat a meal we had thoroughly enjoyed on our first visit.

Unfortunately, this second experience fell well below that standard.

Our first visit earned a 9/10 for food. This time, we would give the food 5/10, the service 6/10, and the ambiance 5/10. We have not calculated an overall score; each rating stands on its own.

The staff members were very nice, but the team appeared stretched too thin. The food did not impress us the way it had previously. Loud music and multiple dogs roaming inside the dining area also affected our enjoyment.

In our opinion, the experience had declined considerably since our visit the previous year. Whether we encountered an off night or something more lasting is a question we cannot answer from one return dinner.

We do, however, plan to try Metate again next year. We remember how good it was, and we would love to see it reach that level again.

At a glance

Explore Metate Cabo

Why We Wanted to Return to Metate

Metate describes its culinary approach as Mexican cooking rooted in traditional techniques, with the metate and molcajete central to its identity (Metate Cabo).

Our reason for returning was simpler: we had enjoyed our first visit enough to want another.

A 9/10 food experience creates anticipation. We arrived remembering a restaurant that had impressed us and expecting another enjoyable evening.

That earlier experience matters to this review. Our disappointment comes from knowing how much better our own previous visit had been.

The lit entrance and Metate sign at night
The lit entrance and Metate sign at night.
The tiled fountain courtyard leading to Metate's covered dining room
The tiled fountain courtyard leading to Metate's covered dining room.
Metate's embroidered-style menu cover
Metate's embroidered-style menu cover.

The Food: From 9/10 on Our First Visit to 5/10 This Time

The biggest disappointment was the difference in the food.

On our first visit, we considered it excellent. During our November 8 return, our assessment was much more ordinary: 5/10.

The meal did not deliver the quality or enjoyment we remembered. We had looked forward to returning, which made the gap between the two visits particularly noticeable.

We cannot say why the experience differed. It may have been an off night. We wondered whether something had changed in the kitchen, but we have no confirmation of any chef or staffing changes.

What we can say is that our second meal was significantly less impressive than our first.

For travelers researching Metate Cabo reviews, that inconsistency is relevant. Our two visits produced very different impressions.

Three salsas served in a carved wooden board at Metate
Three salsas served in a carved wooden board at Metate.
A grilled romaine salad with pickled vegetables and almonds at Metate
A grilled romaine salad with pickled vegetables and almonds at Metate.
A seared fish main course with sauce at Metate
A seared fish main course with sauce at Metate.
Beef rib tacos on yellow and blue corn tortillas at Metate
Beef rib tacos on yellow and blue corn tortillas at Metate.
A large tlayuda-style tortilla with chorizo and pickled onion at Metate
A large tlayuda-style tortilla with chorizo and pickled onion at Metate.
Metate's To Share & Snack menu page
Metate's To Share & Snack menu page.
Metate's Salads, From the Sea and Mains menu page
Metate's Salads, From the Sea and Mains menu page.
Metate's Mains menu page
Metate's Mains menu page.
Metate's Desserts menu page
Metate's Desserts menu page.

Service: Very Nice People, but an Apparently Understaffed Team

Our service rating is 6/10.

The staff members we encountered were very nice. We appreciated their manner and want to give them credit for that.

The difficulty was that the restaurant appeared understaffed during our visit. From our perspective, there were not enough people available to provide the attention the evening needed.

One clear example came at the end of dinner: we waited more than 15 minutes for the check.

That delay was frustrating. By the time you are ready to leave, waiting to settle the bill can unnecessarily drag out an evening.

Our impression was of a friendly team struggling to keep up. We hope management gives the staff the support needed to deliver a smoother experience.

Two cocktails on an embroidered table runner at Metate
Two cocktails on an embroidered table runner at Metate.

Ambiance: A Great Setting Undermined by the Volume

We rated the ambiance 5/10, even though we believe the restaurant’s setting has 10/10 potential.

That was another disappointment. Metate has the makings of a wonderful place to spend an evening, but the conditions during our visit kept us from enjoying it fully.

The music was blaring. For our taste, the volume overwhelmed the dining experience.

Music can contribute energy and personality to a restaurant. During this dinner, we wanted it turned down enough to enjoy the setting and our conversation more comfortably.

That adjustment alone could have made a meaningful difference.

Miriam Peters at a garden table at Metate
Miriam Peters at a garden table at Metate.
The planted garden pond under string lights at Metate
The planted garden pond under string lights at Metate.
Picnic tables on the lawn in Metate's outdoor garden
Picnic tables on the lawn in Metate's outdoor garden.
A DeLorean displayed in Metate's outdoor grounds
A DeLorean displayed in Metate's outdoor grounds.

Multiple Dogs Were Roaming Inside the Dining Area

We also observed multiple dogs roaming inside the restaurant’s dining area.

For us, that detracted from the ambiance. Guests have different comfort levels around animals in restaurants, and it affected our enjoyment of this particular evening.

We are describing what we observed and how we felt about it. We do not know the dogs’ ownership or circumstances.

Together with the loud music, their presence contributed to our lower ambiance rating.

Has Metate Cabo Gone Downhill?

Compared with our own visit the previous year, we felt it had.

That is our honest opinion based on these two experiences. The food was less impressive, service felt stretched, and the atmosphere was harder to enjoy.

We would not claim that every guest will have the same experience or that one disappointing dinner establishes a permanent decline. Our first visit demonstrated that Metate could deliver a much higher standard.

Still, our return fell short in several areas at once. That deserves to be reflected clearly in a firsthand review.

Will We Visit Metate Again?

Yes. We plan to give it another try next year.

Our first visit left enough of a positive impression that we are willing to return. We hope this dinner was an exception and that our next experience will remind us why we enjoyed Metate so much originally.

What would we like to see? Food that meets the earlier standard, sufficient staffing, more comfortable music levels, and a dining environment we can fully enjoy.

We would be happy to write a more enthusiastic review after that experience.

Planning other meals in Cabo? Our November dinners at Casa Martín, Cocina de Autor, Manta, Outpost and Chubby Noodle are reviewed separately, along with our Mexico dining and relaxation guide.

Metate Cabo: Questions Readers Ask

How did you rate Metate Cabo on this visit?

On our November 8, 2026 return we rated the food 5/10, the service 6/10 and the ambiance 5/10. We rated the food 9/10 on our previous visit. We do not combine these into an overall score.

Has Metate Cabo gone downhill?

Compared with our own visit the previous year, we felt it had. That is our personal comparison between two dinners; one disappointing evening does not prove a permanent decline.

Did the kitchen or chef change?

We do not know. We wondered whether something had changed, but we have no confirmation of any chef or staffing changes.

How was the service?

The staff were very nice, but the team appeared understaffed to us. We waited more than 15 minutes for the check.

Will you go back?

Yes. We plan to try Metate again next year and hope it returns to the standard of our first visit.

Peters Signature Travel’s Verdict

Metate Cabo disappointed us on our November 8, 2026 return visit.

The staff was very nice, but service appeared affected by understaffing, including a wait of more than 15 minutes for the check. The food dropped from a 9/10 on our first visit to 5/10 this time. The setting retained its appeal, but blaring music and dogs roaming inside brought our ambiance assessment to 5/10.

We left feeling that the restaurant had fallen below the standard we remembered.

We will try again next year, hoping Metate raises the bar back to the level that first made us want to return.

Continue exploring

Published by Peters Signature Travel.