Our firsthand First Class rankings: Emirates 10/10, Japan Airlines 8/10 and five more carriers. Compare our verdicts plus cabin-air and booking guidance.

By Miriam & Nicholas Peters · Published 2026-11-09
Of the international First Class airlines we have personally flown, Emirates is hands down our favorite. It earns 10/10 and stands clearly ahead of the other airlines in our comparison.
We have personally flown international First Class with Emirates, Air France, British Airways, Cathay Pacific, ANA, Japan Airlines and American Airlines. This is our personal ranking of those seven airlines—not a ranking of cabins we have yet to experience.
Some experiences were good. One was considerably less impressive. Emirates remains the benchmark we want another airline to beat.
Explore Emirates First Class
Ratings reflect our personal flights, not separate scores for every aircraft, route or cabin version. Four airlines share third place; we do not create an artificial order between equal scores.
Emirates is our number-one international First Class airline.
This is the experience that earns our strongest recommendation and the only airline in our comparison to receive 10/10.
When we think about which First Class airline we would most enthusiastically choose again, Emirates is the clear answer. Our enthusiasm comes from having flown it ourselves and comparing that experience with the other airlines listed here.
The difference in our scores is meaningful. Japan Airlines comes next at 8/10, while four airlines share 7/10. Emirates sits distinctly above them in our assessment.
For us, this is what international First Class should aspire to deliver.
We are eager to experience more airlines, but another carrier will have to deliver something exceptional to take the top position.

Japan Airlines ranks second among the international First Class airlines we have experienced.
Our 8/10 reflects a strong impression and places JAL ahead of the four airlines tied below it.
For travelers considering our personal shortlist, Japan Airlines deserves attention. It earned a better score from us than several prominent competitors and stands as our closest challenger to Emirates so far.
It did not reach the same level in our assessment, but it was a good enough experience to secure a clear second place.

Our Air France La Première experience earned 7/10.
That puts it in a four-way tie with British Airways, Cathay Pacific, and ANA.
A 7/10 is a positive assessment, though it falls short of the exceptional experience we associate with our highest rating. Based on our flights, La Première did not displace Emirates or Japan Airlines at the top of our list.
This is our personal impression of the experience we had, rather than a judgment based on reputation or industry awards.

British Airways First also earned 7/10.
Our rating places it alongside Air France, Cathay Pacific, and ANA. We would not create an artificial order between those four airlines when our own scores put them at the same level.
British Airways delivered an experience we rated positively, but it did not become our standout choice for international First Class.
For us, Emirates remains a substantially stronger recommendation.

We rated Cathay Pacific First Class 7/10.
It joins the same middle group in our comparison: good enough for a positive score, without reaching the level of our two highest-rated airlines.
Our experience matters more to this ranking than what we expected before boarding. Whatever an airline’s reputation, we score it according to how we felt about the flights we personally took.
Cathay Pacific earned its place here through that firsthand experience.
ANA First Class earned 7/10, sharing third place with Air France, British Airways, and Cathay Pacific.
Our assessment puts ANA below Japan Airlines in this particular comparison. JAL earned 8/10 from us, giving it the stronger position among the two Japanese airlines we have flown in First Class.
That distinction reflects our own experiences rather than a claim that every traveler—or every flight—will produce the same result.
American Airlines received our lowest score: 5/10.
For clarity, this rating concerns our international Flagship First experience, rather than ordinary domestic First Class.
It left us less impressed than the other airlines in this comparison. At 5/10, it sits well below Emirates and below the standard we would hope for when choosing an international First Class ticket.
Based on our experience, it would not be our first choice when the priority is an exceptional premium journey.
Singapore Airlines, Etihad Airways, Qatar Airways, Lufthansa, SWISS, Qantas, Korean Air, Thai Airways, Garuda Indonesia, Air China, China Eastern, China Southern and Oman Air remain outside this ranking. We have not personally experienced the First Class products contemplated for this list. It is not a statement that every airline currently sells international First Class: some products are historical or limited to particular aircraft and routes.
Business class and international First Class are different categories. A celebrated business-class product should not be inserted into a First Class ranking without being clearly identified.
Our airline scores above assess our personal First Class experiences. They are not measurements of cabin ventilation, humidity, oxygen or infection risk. A private suite or a larger seat should not be treated as evidence of cleaner air.
Ventilation and filtration: the CDC Yellow Book’s air-travel guidance explains that large commercial jets mix outside air with recirculated air that passes through HEPA filters. It describes cabin air being refreshed 20–30 times per hour. That figure describes the ventilation system, not a promise that every passenger’s breathing zone is free of infection risk.
Dry air: the CDC reports typical aircraft cabin humidity of 10–20%, which can dry the eyes and upper airway. Seat luxury and airline reputation are not reliable proxies for cabin humidity; aircraft and operating conditions matter.
Pressure and oxygen: the CDC describes cabin pressure commonly equivalent to an altitude of approximately 6,000–8,000 feet, with some newer aircraft maintaining lower equivalent altitudes. Travelers with cardiopulmonary disease, anemia or a need for supplemental oxygen should discuss flying with their clinician and arrange any required airline assistance before departure.
Close proximity still matters: filtration does not eliminate exposure before contaminated air reaches the filters. The CDC also flags periods when ventilation is off, including some ground delays, boarding and deplaning. More personal space is a comfort benefit, not a guarantee against airborne illness.
Our practical approach is to compare the actual aircraft and seat for comfort, while treating health precautions as a separate decision. Follow current public-health advice and consult a clinician about personal medical needs rather than choosing an airline on an unsupported “best cabin air” claim.
Confirm the cabin name on every flight segment. A journey sold with a First Class long-haul segment may include connections in business or another cabin. Domestic First Class and international Flagship First are not interchangeable in our American Airlines assessment.
Check the aircraft and seat map for the particular departure. An airline can operate multiple cabin generations, and a substitution can change the seat you receive. Our reference photographs show identifiable cabin designs, including historical ones; they do not establish our aircraft or today’s availability.
Compare the complete itinerary, connection time, ticket flexibility and written inclusions. Do not assume that lounge access, ground services, onboard showers or a specific meal come with every First Class ticket.
Our strongest preference remains Emirates, followed by Japan Airlines. Use that preference as one input alongside the cabin actually being sold, your travel dates and the practicality of the route.
Emirates is our clear favorite among the seven airlines we have personally flown, earning 10/10. Japan Airlines ranks second at 8/10.
Air France La Première, British Airways First, Cathay Pacific First Class and ANA First Class each earned 7/10 from us. We preserve that tie rather than inventing an order.
No. Our 5/10 concerns our international Flagship First experience, not ordinary domestic First Class.
No such guarantee is supported by our experience ratings. Cabin ventilation depends on the aircraft and operating conditions, and filtration does not remove all person-to-person airborne risk.
The CDC describes typical aircraft cabin humidity as 10–20%, which can dry the eyes and upper airway.
They are credited reference photographs of identifiable cabin designs, including historical cabins. They do not establish our flight dates, routes or aircraft, or guarantee the product available to book today.
Emirates First Class: 10/10. Our clear winner. Japan Airlines follows at 8/10. Air France, British Airways, Cathay Pacific and ANA share 7/10; American Airlines International Flagship First earns 5/10.
Emirates is the best international First Class we have personally flown—and the one everyone else has to beat. Confirm the actual cabin before booking, and keep cabin-air health questions separate from a luxury-experience ranking.
Published by Peters Signature Travel.