Escape the city for the understated elegance of the East End. our team reveal the most refined coastal corners of Long Island's lighthouse shores.
The drive east along Route 27 is a transition of light as much as it is a change of scenery. By the time you pass Amagansett and the road narrows into the Napeague Stretch, the air shifts—the salt content rises, the humidity softens, and the manicured manicured lawns of Southampton give way to something more skeletal, wind-swept, and profound.
We have spent decades navigating the East End. We have seen the Hamptons at their loudest, and we have sought them at their quietest. What actually matters in this corner of the world isn't the size of the hedge or the label on the bottle; it is the quality of the stillness and the integrity of the service. In Montauk, the "End of the World" moniker holds a different weight now. It is no longer a sleepy fishing village, nor is it merely a playground for the Manhattan exodus. It has become a case study in how luxury can coexist with grit—provided you know where to look.
This is our curated navigation of Montauk, where we examine what delivers—and where the polish occasionally wears thin.
In Montauk, luxury is often a choice between the cinematic and the secluded. Many visitors stumble by choosing a property that mimics a Midtown aesthetic; in editorial experience, the only way to experience this coastline is to embrace the Atlantic as the primary interior designer.
What sets this apart: It is the proximity to the surf. You aren't just near the water; the ocean spray is a permanent fixture on your balcony glass. The aesthetic is heavily influenced by Japanese minimalism and the 1960s surf culture of the area.
The Critique: While the "digital detox" ethos is lovely on paper, the lack of traditional amenities—like a fully-equipped gym or extensive room service menu—will frustrate those used to the seamlessness of Manhattan’s best luxury hotels. Marram is for the traveler who finds luxury in a perfectly brewed cup of coffee and the sound of the tide, not the one who needs a 24-hour concierge to source a specific vintage of Bordeaux.
Where it delivers: The Seawater Spa is genuinely world-class. The thalassotherapy pool, fed by filtered ocean water, is one of the few places in North America that honors European spa traditions with precision. The light in the treatment rooms is ethereal, filtered through sea-misted glass.
Where it doesn't: During the height of July and August, the beach club can feel transactional. The "scene" often overshadows the scenery. If you value silence, Gurney’s is best experienced during the shoulder seasons—those crisp September mornings when the crowds have thinned but the water remains warm enough for a morning plunge.
Dining in Montauk has moved beyond the simple lobster roll, though the integrity of the local catch remains the benchmark.
Back to The Journal: Travel Stories & Destination Guides
Hotel reviews · Destinations · Best hotels · Compare hotels · The Journal · Plan & Book
Published by Peters Signature Travel.