Aman New York vs Four Seasons Surf Club: Which to Book

Aman New York vs Four Seasons Surf Club: compare location, accommodation, dining and trip fit before choosing your room and checking current rates.

Aman New York for a base in Fifth Avenue & 57th Street, NYC; Four Seasons Surf Club for Surfside, Miami

Our verdict

Aman New York is based in Fifth Avenue & 57th Street, NYC; Four Seasons Surf Club is based in Surfside, Miami. Choose the destination first: these stays involve different routes and surrounding experiences. Consider urban sanctuary accommodation at Aman New York against beach resort accommodation at Four Seasons Surf Club. The property notes below outline dining, setting and seasonal considerations. Compare equivalent dates, occupancy and inclusions before deciding on value; a starting-rate estimate or a composite score cannot settle that decision.

Aman New York — Fifth Avenue & 57th Street, NYC

Three-floor spa with 25m indoor pool — NYC's most exclusive wellness space

• Strengths: Three-floor spa with 25m indoor pool — NYC's most exclusive wellness space; Nama for Japanese omakase; Arva for Italian; the Jazz Club for cocktails; 25,000 sq ft spa across three floors with two pools and fireplace lounges
• Trade-offs: Seasonal planning: Year-round; Match the exact Aman New York property and room category before comparing quotes.; Check the final total for your dates, occupancy, taxes, transfers and meal inclusions.; Confirm cancellation deadlines, bedding and access requirements with the booking provider.
• Best for: Aman devotees, Wellness seekers, Ultra-luxury NYC stays
• Dining: Nama for Japanese omakase; Arva for Italian; the Jazz Club for cocktails
• Room to book: Compare the room layout, view and inclusions against your itinerary. Confirm occupancy, bedding and the cancellation policy for the specific category before booking Aman New York.

Four Seasons Surf Club — Surfside, Miami

Le Sirenuse and Thomas Keller's Surf Club Restaurant — dual destination dining

• Strengths: Le Sirenuse and Thomas Keller's Surf Club Restaurant — dual destination dining; Thomas Keller's Surf Club Restaurant and Le Sirenuse Miami — extraordinary pairing; Four Seasons spa with oceanfront treatment rooms
• Trade-offs: Seasonal planning: Year-round, best Nov–May; Match the exact Four Seasons Surf Club property and room category before comparing quotes.; Check the final total for your dates, occupancy, taxes, transfers and meal inclusions.; Confirm cancellation deadlines, bedding and access requirements with the booking provider.
• Best for: Thomas Keller fans, Art Deco lovers, Quiet beach seekers
• Dining: Thomas Keller's Surf Club Restaurant and Le Sirenuse Miami — extraordinary pairing
• Room to book: Compare the room layout, view and inclusions against your itinerary. Confirm occupancy, bedding and the cancellation policy for the specific category before booking Four Seasons Surf Club.

Choose Aman New York when

• Your itinerary is centred on Fifth Avenue & 57th Street, NYC.
• You are looking for urban sanctuary accommodation rather than choosing on brand reputation alone.
• Your priorities include aman devotees, wellness seekers, ultra-luxury nyc stays.
• You prefer a trip based in New York rather than Miami.
• The specific room, final quote and cancellation conditions fit your plans.

Choose Four Seasons Surf Club when

• Your itinerary is centred on Surfside, Miami.
• You are looking for beach resort accommodation rather than choosing on brand reputation alone.
• Your priorities include thomas keller fans, art deco lovers, quiet beach seekers.
• You prefer a trip based in Miami rather than New York.
• The specific room, final quote and cancellation conditions fit your plans.

Keep comparing

More head-to-heads with Aman New York

• Aman New York vs Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown — New York
• Aman Tokyo vs Aman New York
• Amangiri vs Aman New York — United States
• Aman New York vs The Mark — New York

More head-to-heads with Four Seasons Surf Club

• Four Seasons Surf Club vs Faena Hotel Miami Beach — Miami
• Four Seasons Surf Club vs The Mark — Miami vs New York
• Four Seasons Surf Club vs Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown — Miami vs New York
• Four Seasons Surf Club vs The Beverly Hills Hotel — Miami vs Beverly Hills

Elsewhere in North America

• The Mark vs Four Seasons Hotel New York Downtown — New York
• Hotel Bel-Air vs The Beverly Hills Hotel — Beverly Hills
• The Little Nell vs The St. Regis Aspen Resort — Aspen
• Aman New York vs The Beverly Hills Hotel — New York vs Beverly Hills

Go deeper

• Aman New York hotel guide — Property coverage and room considerations
• All hotel head-to-heads — Browse the full comparison index
• Best luxury travel companies 2026 — Compare company specialisms and booking terms

Published by Peters Signature Travel.